Mrs. K's Little Piece of the Internet
Mrs. K's Literature Place
Archives
A blog for students of Mrs. K at Lutheran High North
Monday, August 25, 2003
From Brian Fielder:
The Lottery
1. Yes, the ending did suprise me. I would have never expected death to result from something as innocent as a lottery especially when you win it or in this case lose. I guess back then it was just a way to control population or something.
2. Tradition played a major role in this story. Everybody knew the date for the lottery and it had become routine. No one questioned the process they all went along with it. Tradition plays a huge role in our lives. Many people follow certain practices and customs that are part of their heritage or background which make them unique and different from everyone else.
A Modest Proposal
1. Wow that was weird. If you think about it, it kind of makes sense because it would help the poor, benefit the rich, and help control the population. However, it is kind of sick and twisted if you think about it. This person has all the right reasons but just the wrong solution.
A Sound of Thunder
1. Yes I think it could because all life is connected in a chain. If you disrupt it then it could lead to major outcomes. I am not sure if butterflies pollinate plants but if they do then it could lead to an extinction of certain plants that were eaten by animals that were eaten by humans. It could have also affected the whole migration patterns of animals and early humans.
2. I think I would go back some time during during Bible times. I think it would be cool if I could witness the flood, ancient Egypt, Christ's birth, death, and resurrection, and even all of his miracles.
Saturday, August 09, 2003
Hello Folks!!
Thanks for all your hard work this summer...I hope you've enjoyed the stories and the book. We'll talk about Harrison Bergeron when we get to class next week, but be thinking about equality and what it means in society today - that's our launching point!
Make sure you have the F451 worksheets ready for the first week of school...we are going to take off like a shot!! I'm ready - hope YOU are!!
Enjoy your last couple of days of freedom...muahahahahahaha!!!
Mrs. K
Monday, July 21, 2003
Oh man, do I disagree with you guys. The time to which Eckels and company traveled back was near the beginning. What if that WAS the only butterfly? What if all beauty in humankind died with the butterfly in the sole of his shoe?
Here's an interesting essay....
VALUING ENDANGERED SPECIES
By Rodger Schlickeisen
Some opponents of the Endangered Species Act see imperiled life forms as nothing but
metaphors for excessive regulation, lost jobs, and foregone profits. They’d like nothing better
than for them to go extinct and thus get out of the way of “progress.” As the president of the
anti-environmental American Farm Bureau Federation put it recently, “Take endangered species,
please.”
To anyone more slightly tempted by such a self-indulgent perspective, I suggest a simple
exercise. Pick up the list of the more than 1,000 U.S. species now protected by the Endangered
Species Act and run your eyes over the names. Consider America without the grizzly bear, gray
wolf, ocelot, Florida manatee, woodland caribou. The bald eagle, whooping crane, peregrine
falcon, brown pelican, piping plover, spotted owl, wood stork, white-faced ibis, roseate tern,
snail kite, golden-cheeked warbler. The desert tortoise, California red-legged frog and American
crocodile. Four sturgeon and seven trout species and several chinook, coho and sockeye salmon
populations. A lengthening list of clams, snails, beetles, butterflies. Hine’s emerald dragonfly and
the Nashville crayfish. Hundreds of wildflowers and other plants, including more than a dozen
fern species. And so many, many more.
What are endangered species? They are the warmth, joy and glory of being alive amid the
vast diversity of living things - big and small, delicate and mighty. They are the vital ingredients
of landscapes whose resulting harmony is welcome counterpoint to the chaos of modern human
existence. They are the instruments that make the music of nature, producing a symphony
delightful to the ears and soothing to stress-filled minds.
Endangered species are the memories of childhood, that carefree sunny afternoons were made
of. They are the beetles and snails, butterflies and dragonflies endlessly pursued and carefully
captured to be admired in mason jars with freshly picked grass and newly aerated lids.
Endangered species are the rhythm of the seasons. They are the migrating birds whose sweet
songs announce each spring, the wildflowers that scent and color the summer meadow, the earthtoned
leaves that fall on crisp autumn mornings, and the tracks of predator and prey acting out
age-old dramas across the winter snow.
Endangered species are the inspiration for countless books, songs, poems, paintings,
photographs and sculptures that enrich our culture beyond measure. They are Henry David
Thoreau, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Walt Whitman, Mark Twain, Robert Service, John Muir, A.B.
Guthrie, Emily Dickinson, Rachel Carson, Aldo Leopold, Wallace Stegner, John James
Audubon, Ansel Adams, Frederick Remington, Charlie Russell, Aaron Copland and many more
whose inspiring works are tribute to a natural world now at risk.
Endangered species are the essence of wild nature. They are the hunter and hunted whose
behavior has determined the characteristics of countless animals, making bison tough, antelope
swift and mountain goats nimble. They are the excitement and adventure that only wildness can
offer.
Endangered species are the frontier challenges that shaped the unique American character.
They are the at-risk survivors of the clash between ever-advancing civilization and constantly
retreating nature, but also the salvation of that civilization which gains perspective, vitality and
balance from a world where nature’s challenges still exist and where ultimate freedom and
independence still prevail.
Endangered species are a warning that the margin between existence and extinction is
narrowing, and that millions of years of evolutionary processes are being forever altered. They
are a signal that the web of life of the future will be much less rich and complex, with uncertain
consequences for all species, including our own.
Endangered species are a reminder that all living things are part of creation and have their
own dignity and intrinsic worth apart from any value that we might bestow. But they are also
species threatened by a fate worse than death, now surviving only precariously in life’s shadows,
midway between being and not being-innocent victims of human actions at odds with true
humanity.
This is what endangered species are today. Their tomorrow depends upon society’s
willingness to adopt a wiser, more compassionate and morally superior view of progress. So does
our own.
Rodger Schlickeisen is the president of Defenders of Wildlife. He will welcome your comments.
Send him an email at Rodger@Defenders.org
More food for thought :-)
Sunday, July 20, 2003
"A Sound of Thunder"
I thought that the chain reaction of the death of the butterfly wouldn't really affect such things as language and society. If you think about it from a chain-reaction perspective, then humans most likely wouldn't even be alive (the butterfly's death led to the death of something else, and so on, and eventually to the death of humans).
I would really like to go back to either ancient Egypt or the Victorian times, because those eras interest me :). I love the different ideas the Egyptians had about the world then, and how much their surroundings affected them. I also think the Victorian times were interesting because the new ideas in our society were beginning to come about, like women's rights and help for the poor.
Thursday, July 10, 2003
For the five or six of you who are just joining us...I thought I would repost all the questions in one easy-to-manage place :-)
THE LOTTERY - Shirley Jackson
First of all, did the ending surprise you?
Secondly, discuss the role of tradition in the story. How important is it? How does it affect us?
Thirdly (and optionally) post a strange or funny family tradition :-)
A MODEST PROPOSAL – Jonathan Swift
After you read "A Modest Proposal", I just want you to post your reaction...we'll go from there!
A SOUND OF THUNDER – Ray Bradbury
1. Do you think the outcome from one butterfly could be that monumental? How? Why?
2. If you could choose a time to return to, when would it be? Why?
How can a single butterfly affect language? Here's something to think about. The original poetry was spoken, not written. What if man was never inspired by something beautiful that God created? What if man never decided "I have to somehow save this because it is so beautiful?" and looked for a way to keep things...thus inventing language. What if our language was born, but changed forever by the lack of beauty in the world? What if, when English was created in Anglo-Saxon England, no love or gentleness was ever introduced...just warfare?
Hey, I don't have answers...just questions. :-)
Keep writing!!
Monday, July 07, 2003
NEW QUESTION DAY!!
Hello, fellow scholars :-) Today's new question is about "A Sound of Thunder", which is truly from the Sci Fi genre, since it involves technology and the future - and it's one of my favorite stories. Here are your discussion topics:
1. Do you think the outcome from one butterfly could be that monumental? How? Why?
2. If you could choose a time to return to, when would it be? Why?
Wednesday, July 02, 2003
..there will be a new question coming on Monday, July 7...keep posting about "The Lottery" and "A Modest Proposal" too - just be sure to label which story you are talking about!!
You really didn't think "A Modest Proposal" was funny? I think it's hysterical...as satire. If Swift were SERIOUS, that would be another matter!!!
Monday, June 30, 2003
I read the story before realizing it was a satire. I was horrified! Altough I've got to hand it to the author, he did present his case really well. I just couldn't believe someone would put that much thought into cannibalism. Yuck! I also loved the line "...and besides, it is not improbable that some scrupulous people might be apt to censure such a practice, (although indeed very unjustly) as a little bordering upon cruelty..." Hmmm... just a little cruel, huh?
Sunday, June 22, 2003
Hello, Fellow Scholars!!
If you haven't yet begun to read "A Modest Proposal", I will warn you now it's the hardest piece of the summer...but it's probably the most interesting. It's a tad difficult in language because it was written in 1729. It was written by Jonathan Swift, the author of "Gulliver's Travels". It is a satire - look it up, if you aren't sure of the genre.
With satire, the object is to poke fun at a problem, or at a tradition, or at an established item - sort of like MAD or CRACKED magazine do today. Or MadTV, or Saturday Night Live.
After you read "A Modest Proposal", I just want you to post your reaction...we'll go from there.
Friday, June 20, 2003
Any last responses to the Lottery? I'm going to post a new question on Sunday!!!!
